Malpractice Lawsuit Claims Idaho Doctors Accidentally Removed Patient’s Kidney

Malpractice Lawsuit Claims Idaho Doctors Accidentally Removed Patient’s Kidney

Last year when Roland N. Smith, 83-years-old, learned that he had a cancerous tumor growing on his right kidney he was relieved to learn that it could be safely removed. By the time Smith arrived at the Idaho Falls hospital for surgery the tumor had grown to the size of a grapefruit. Despite the growth he was assured by the surgical team at Mountain View Hospital that the operation was safe to proceed as scheduled. What he did not bother to confirm was that they would perform the surgery on the right kidney and not the left one. But according to a malpractice lawsuit filed by Smith, the attending surgeons, Roger H. Tall and David J. Chamberlain, operated on and accidentally removed his perfectly healthy left kidney.

According to Smith’s attorney, on August 23, 2016 Tall and Chamberlain conducted the surgery without reviewing the documents that clearly stated the tumor was on his right kidney. In addition, the doctors were only supposed to remove the tumor and not the kidney itself. Court documents show that in July 2016, Smith’s radiologist mislabeled a report stating that the tumor was on the left kidney and not the right one. This does not explain, however, why the surgeons completely removed the kidney. Especially because a camera was used during the surgery so they should have seen that there was no tumor and stopped the operation.

“Instead,” according to the malpractice lawsuit, “in complete disregard of the most fundamental medical safety standards, the group surgically removed Smith’s healthy, non-cancerous left kidney, leaving his cancerous and lethal right kidney undisturbed and intact.”

After the surgery the kidney was sent to the pathology department for analysis and the doctors were informed that the organ was healthy. Yet Smith’s attorney claims that the doctors in question filed a false report stating that the procedure was “completely uneventful.” In addition, a week after Smith’s discharge, Tall wrote that the kidney was taken out after the analysis of his medical scans. But the malpractice lawsuit states that the doctors did not carefully scrutinize the scans or else they would’ve taken out the tumor and not the healthy kidney.
The malpractice lawsuit filed in Bonneville County is now pending. Smith’s lawyers are seeking financial compensation for any future and past medical costs as well as the physical and emotional pain caused by the alleged negligence.


Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Does It Take For Levaquin To Leave The Body?
27 aug
How Long Does It Take For Levaquin To Leave The Body?

If the patient generally has good health, the body can eliminate Levaquin (levofloxacin) in about 30 to 40 hours, or about a day and a half to two days, but some side effects of the drug can show up as long as two months or longer after taking the medicine. Some of the adverse reactions

Read More
How Many Patients Die in Treatment Centers from Alcohol Detoxification?
12 jun
How Many Patients Die in Treatment Centers from Alcohol Detoxification?

It is difficult to track how many patients die in treatment centers during alcohol detoxification in the United States. We do, however, know there are thousands of treatment facilities nationwide that serve those hoping to break their dependence on drugs or alcohol. This number includes the treatment centers where more than 3,300 people died during

Read More