Do Most Medical Malpractice Cases Go to Trial?

Do Most Medical Malpractice Cases Go to Trial? Most medical malpractices cases never make it to trial.

According to Business Insurance report, of the hundreds of lawsuits filed every year, only about half of medical malpractice cases go to trial. Fewer than 5 percent end in a verdict. Over 95 percent of medical malpractice claims result in out-of-court settlements. Hospitals and doctors are often eager to settle to avoid the potential of facing a much larger judgment in court, while patients agree to settle to get paid quickly and avoid the protracted legal process, which can take several years to reach a resolution.

If you were a victim of medical negligence and are considering a lawsuit, settling out of court is an option to keep in mind as you begin the process. Depending on the strength of your case, the amount of money you are seeking, and other circumstances, you might find it advantageous to have your attorney negotiate an out-of-court settlement. In other situations, it makes more sense to go to trial and argue the case in front of a jury.

The legal team at Newsome Melton focuses on complex litigation. Our attorneys know how to negotiate settlements with medical providers to get our clients fair compensation, and we have also fought and won many cases at trial. We invite you to sit down with us to discuss the details of your case and go over your options. The consultation and case review are free and come with no obligations. To schedule an appointment today, call us at 1-855-MED-ASKS.

Will I Win More Money by Going to Trial or Settling out of Court?

The answer to this question depends on the specifics of your case. If you settle out of court, you are guaranteed compensation, though it might not be as much as you would have received in a trial. If you go to trial, you have the potential for a more substantial award, but it is not guaranteed. A chance always exists that the judge or jury will rule against you.

According to a 2013 report from Medscape, the average out-of-court settlement for medical malpractice claims was about $425,000. The average jury award in the same year exceeded $1 million. Claimants who went to trial and won their cases took home more than double what their counterparts who settled out of court received.

However, these figures only consider those who won in court, not instances where the judge threw out the case or the jury ruled unfavorably. A 2012 study that looked at claims filed between 2002 and 2005 revealed nearly 80 percent of jury verdicts were in the physician’s favor.

The numbers also fail to take into account time concerns. Settling out of court almost always results in a much faster payment as compared to going to trial.

What Are the Benefits of Not Going to Trial?

If the physician, facility, or other party you are suing is agreeable to settling out of court, you and your attorney have a decision to make. Should you agree to a settlement or continue to trial?

Much of this decision rests on the amount the at-fault party is willing to pay in a settlement. If it is significantly less than what you are seeking in court and you feel your case is thorough and compelling, it might not make sense to settle. That said, the out-of-court settlement process is a negotiation, not a simple yes-or-no question. You do not have to accept the initial offer put in front of you. This is why it is essential to have an aggressive attorney who will fight for what you deserve.

Settling out of court offers two primary benefits: speed and security. A jury trial can take years to conclude. That is a long time to wait for compensation, particularly if you have expensive medical bills to pay for or you have had to miss work while recovering from your injuries or illness.

With an out-of-court settlement, you can avoid the red tape of the legal process and get paid quickly and directly by the provider or physician.

An out-of-court settlement also provides more security, as your fate does not depend on the whim of a judge or jury. When a doctor or facility agrees to settle out of court, you at least know you are going to get something.

How Can I Discuss My Legal Options With an Attorney?

The Newsome Melton legal team wants to help you get the best outcome from your medical malpractice claim, whether that be in court or out of court. To schedule a free consultation, call 1-855-MED-ASKS.

Legal Information - News Articles

Florida Supreme Court Rules On Secret Ex Parte Interviews
21 nov
Florida Supreme Court Rules On Secret Ex Parte Interviews

Florida Supreme Court Rules Secret Ex Parte Interviews of  Medical Malpractice Plaintiffs’ Doctors Unconstitutional  On November 9, 2017, the Florida Supreme Court issued its highly anticipated decision in Weaver v. Myers, No. SC15-1538 (Nov. 9, 2017).  In Weaver, the Supreme Court struck two provisions pertaining to secret, ex parte interviews with plaintiffs’ healthcare providers in connection

Read More
Debunking Medical Malpractice Fallacies: Three Popular Defense Myths
31 jan
Debunking Medical Malpractice Fallacies: Three Popular Defense Myths

Several myths about medical negligence and malpractice suits have become popular recently, particularly as healthcare and insurance costs continued to be a major focus of economic and political debate.  Below are three of the major myths tort reform proponents use to help push their agenda to limit the ability of injured patients to seek compensation

Read More