Pennsylvania State Supreme Court May Allow ‘Error In Judgment’ In Medical Malpractice Cases

Pennsylvania State Supreme Court May Allow ‘Error In Judgment’ In Medical Malpractice Cases

Last week, it was announced that the state Supreme Court of Pennsylvania would discuss whether or not to overturn a law that allows defendants in medical malpractice lawsuits to avoid prosecution based on “error in judgment”. The decision came as Stephen and Nicole Passarello were granted a new trial after their original lawsuit was dismissed because of the defense’s argument that a physician’s error in judgment does not qualify as negligence.

The new decision is based on a 2009 ruling in the case of Pringle v. Rapaport that essentially eliminated error in judgment as a viable excuse for a malpractice lawsuit. Said Judge John T. Bender at the time of that decision:

“‘Under the law physicians are permitted a broad range of judgment in their professional duties and physicians are not liable for errors of judgment unless it’s proven that an error of judgment was the result of negligence…’”

Dr. Rowena Grumbine responded to complaints by the Passarello family that their 2-year old son was not eating and was coughing and vomiting with a diagnosis of gastroesophageal reflux. Their son eventually died in the emergency room from acute viral myocarditis, which is a serious heart disorder.

Grumbine and her counsel have argued that a physician’s judgment will always be subject to error and that overturning this decision would essentially require doctors to be perfect. Grumbine’s representation has also argued that she went above and beyond her call of duty to diagnose the boy; however, the family and its counsel maintain that the error was too egregious to be dismissed as typical.

Source:

Zack Needles, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. (06/11/2012) “Justices to consider ‘error in judgment’ medical malpractice defense”.


Frequently Asked Questions

What Happens If Someone Dies From Medical Malpractice?
08 aug
What Happens If Someone Dies From Medical Malpractice?

Medical errors are a leading cause of death in the United States. Although some errors are unavoidable, a large number are preventable, meaning many patients lose their lives each year due to medical malpractice. If someone dies from medical malpractice, their family members can recover damages to pay for their losses. If your loved one

Read More
What Should You Do Before You Call a Medical Malpractice Lawyer & Open a Claim?
19 mar
What Should You Do Before You Call a Medical Malpractice Lawyer & Open a Claim?

Malpractice cases are notoriously complex and difficult to litigate, so it is essential you go about it the right way. In most medical malpractice situations, there are a few things you should consider doing before calling a medical malpractice lawyer and filing suit: Learn about the statute of limitations in your state Talk to the

Read More